GoodMart Lighting and Electrical Supply
www.goodmart.com
877-402-6100
Analysis of Typical Metal Halide Idustrial Lighting Systems with
Energy Saving Alternatives
Metal Halide, Energy Saving Metal Halide, Metal Halide Pulse Start
Systems and High Efficiency Fluorescent Lighting Systems
|
| |
Good |
Better |
Better Still |
Best |
| Bulb |
175W Standard Metal Halide
|
150W Energy Saver Metal Halide
|
125W Pulse Start Metal Halide
|
Four 28W 4ft T8 Fluorescent Tubes
|
| Ballast |
175W CWA Ballast
|
175W CWA Ballast
|
125W Pulse Start Ballast
|
Four Lamp L.P. QHE Ballast
|
| Mean Lumens per Watt |
43 |
46 |
56 |
101 |
| Mean Lumens |
9,100 |
8,800 |
8,400 |
8,500 |
| Average Rated Life |
10,000 |
10,000 |
15,000 |
18,000 |
| System Watts |
210 |
190 |
150 |
84 |
| Annual Operating Cost* |
$84.00 |
$76.00 |
$60.00 |
$33.60 |
| Notes |
|
No ballast change required |
Assumes BU Operating Position |
New Fixture Required |
| |
Good |
Better |
Better Still |
Best |
| Bulb |
250W Standard Metal Halide
|
225W Energy Saver Metal Halide
|
200W Pulse Start Metal Halide
|
Six 28W 4ft T8 Fluorescent Tubes
|
| Ballast |
250W CWA Ballast
|
250W CWA Ballast
|
200W Pulse Start Ballast
|
2x Three Lamp QHE Ballasts
|
| Mean Lumens per Watt |
47 |
46 |
74 |
100 |
| Mean Lumens |
13,700 |
12,400 |
16,000 |
14,390 |
| Average Rated Life |
10,000 |
10,000 |
15,000 |
18,000 |
| System Watts |
294 |
270 |
215 |
144 |
| Annual Operating Cost* |
$117.60 |
$108.00 |
$86.00 |
$57.60 |
| Notes |
|
No ballast change required |
Assumes BU Operating Position |
New Fixture Required |
| |
Good |
Better |
Better Still |
Best |
| Bulb |
400W Standard Metal Halide
|
360W Energy Saver Metal Halide
|
300W Pulse Start Metal Halide
|
Eight 32W 4ft T8 XP Fluorescent Tubes
|
| Ballast |
400W CWA Ballast
|
400W CWA Ballast
|
400W Pulse Start Ballast
|
2x Four Lamp QHE Ballasts
|
| Mean Lumens per Watt |
52 |
59 |
575 |
99 |
| Mean Lumens |
23,400 |
23,400 |
24,400 |
21,120 |
| Average Rated Life |
20,000 |
20,000 |
20,000 |
18,000 |
| System Watts |
450 |
400 |
325 |
215 |
| Annual Operating Cost* |
$180.00 |
$160.00 |
$130.00 |
$86.00 |
| Notes |
|
No ballast change required |
Assumes BU Operating Position |
New Fixture Required |
|
*Annual Operating Cost assumes 4,000 hours/yr. at $0.10 per kWh
|
 |
|